By Editorial Staff
May 26, 2026
In the book of Deuteronomy, the biblical mandate is clear: "Choose life." For centuries, this has been interpreted as a call to action—a directive to pursue vitality, ethics, and longevity. But in the modern era, particularly for those navigating the harrowing terrain of a life-altering illness, the definition of "choosing life" has evolved into a complex, multi-faceted endeavor. It involves rigorous treatment protocols, self-care, and the relentless pursuit of remission. Yet, there is a missing piece to this puzzle: the courage to prepare for the inevitable.
Rabbi Melanie Levav, BCC, LMSW, and Executive Director of the Shomer Collective, posits that true vitality is not found in avoiding the reality of death, but in integrating it into our life’s journey. By examining the intersection of medical necessity and spiritual wisdom, we find that planning for the end is not a surrender—it is the ultimate act of living with intention.
The Disconnect: Statistics vs. Reality
The chasm between our intentions and our actions regarding end-of-life planning remains one of the most significant sociological gaps in American life. According to recent data, 92% of Americans agree that it is critically important to discuss their wishes for end-of-life care. This consensus spans across age, socioeconomic status, and religious background.
However, the reality on the ground is starkly different: only one-third of Americans have actually engaged in these conversations or formalized their wishes through advance directives or legal planning. This disparity reveals a deep-seated cultural aversion to what many call "the D words"—death and dying. We have been conditioned to focus exclusively on the positive, to project optimism, and to equate the discussion of mortality with a lack of hope.
This cultural silence, however, comes at a high price. When families are forced to make decisions during a medical crisis without the benefit of prior guidance, the emotional burden is compounded by the agony of uncertainty.
A Patient’s Perspective: The Power of Preparation
For Meredith L., a beneficiary of support from both Sharsheret and the Shomer Collective, the shock of a cancer diagnosis was mitigated by a pre-existing foundation of communication.
"My cancer diagnosis was really scary," Meredith reflects. "I was thankful that a lot of basic things like wills and medical decisions were already something that Ben and I spoke about, so I didn’t have to include that in my additional planning."
Her experience underscores the relief that comes from "doing the work" while one is still healthy—or at least, before the medical crisis reaches a fever pitch. Meredith highlights the specific value of organizations like Sharsheret, which bridge the gap between clinical necessity and emotional, cultural support. "It feels so reassuring to know that there’s a place that not only understands the medical side of it but the Jewish heritage side as well," she notes. By meeting patients where they are, these organizations transform the daunting task of end-of-life planning into a manageable, even empowering, process.
Chronology of Awareness: From Taboo to Transparency
The movement toward "death literacy" has been a slow evolution. Historically, death was a communal, domestic event. In the mid-20th century, the medicalization of dying moved this process into hospitals, distancing families from the reality of the end-of-life experience.
- The Early 20th Century: Death was primarily managed at home, with family and clergy as the primary stewards.
- The Mid-20th Century: The rise of clinical medicine brought life-saving interventions but also created a "taboo" surrounding the discussion of death. Dying became something that happened "in" a hospital, often behind closed doors.
- The Early 21st Century: The emergence of the palliative care movement began to shift the conversation back toward patient-centered goals.
- 2020–2026: The global pandemic, combined with an aging population and advancements in oncology, has forced a societal reckoning. There is a growing movement—spearheaded by groups like the Shomer Collective—to normalize conversations about mortality, viewing them as essential to mental health and family cohesion.
Ancient Wisdom for Modern Challenges
The Jewish tradition offers a unique lens through which to view this modern dilemma. In the Talmud, Rabbi Eliezer teaches that one should "repent one day before they die." When his students asked how one could possibly know which day would be their last, the answer became a guiding principle: live every day in a state of preparedness.
This is not a call to morbidity, but a call to urgency. If tomorrow is never guaranteed, the wisdom suggests, then the things that truly matter—our values, our relationships, and our legacies—should be attended to today.
Rabbi Levav emphasizes that this perspective is applicable to everyone, regardless of health status. "We are all born mortal," she notes. By confronting this fact, we strip death of its power to paralyze us. Instead, we reclaim the agency to define how we want to live our remaining days.
Implications: The Gift of Planning
What are the practical implications of shifting our cultural narrative? The benefits are both immediate and long-term:
- Reducing Caregiver Burden: When a patient’s wishes are documented, the agonizing "what-if" scenarios for family members are eliminated. They are empowered to be advocates rather than crisis-managers.
- Increased Autonomy: Advance directives and end-of-life conversations ensure that the medical care received aligns with the patient’s personal values and religious or ethical beliefs.
- Enhanced Connection: Surprisingly, couples and families who discuss mortality often report a deeper sense of intimacy. Facing the limit of time forces a conversation about priorities, which often leads to the resolution of long-standing conflicts and the reinforcement of bonds.
- Living with Intention: When the "business of death" is handled, the psychological energy previously spent on anxiety about the future is liberated. This allows the individual to focus entirely on the quality of their present life.
Moving Forward: A Call to Action
The journey toward a more death-literate society is not one that can be taken by institutions alone; it requires individual participation. The invitation is to move past the fear, the avoidance, and the societal pressures to stay "forever young."
As we consider the path forward, we must ask ourselves: What matters most? Is it the comfort of silence, or the clarity of a shared plan?
The Shomer Collective and Sharsheret serve as beacons in this transition, reminding us that we do not have to walk this path alone. They provide the frameworks, the conversations, and the compassionate guidance needed to navigate the intersection of life and death.
In the final analysis, the most profound way to honor the mandate to "choose life" is to live in such a way that when the end comes, our loved ones are left with a clear understanding of our values and the peace of mind that comes from knowing we lived—and planned—exactly as we intended.
The question remains: What matters most to you, and what are you going to do about it today?
About the Author
