By Editorial Staff
September 19, 2025
The arrival of the High Holy Days, particularly Rosh Hashanah, typically serves as a time of collective reflection, renewal, and the anticipation of sweetness. Central to this tradition is the iconic image of dipping an apple into honey—a ritual steeped in historical significance and symbolic aspiration. However, for the thousands of individuals navigating a cancer diagnosis, this season of joy often carries a profound emotional undercurrent.
As Shera Dubitsky, Senior Advisor at Sharsheret, notes, the intersection of illness and tradition requires a delicate re-evaluation. While the honey symbolizes a desire for a year that is “precious, enjoyable, peaceful, and protected,” the reality for patients and survivors is frequently far from sweet.
The Weight of Tradition: When Ritual Meets Adversity
For many, the holidays are not merely a calendar event but a crucible of emotional and physical exertion. The traditional preparation—shopping, cooking, and hosting—often feels like an insurmountable mountain when one is battling the physiological exhaustion of chemotherapy, the mental fatigue of radiation, or the existential anxiety of a terminal or chronic prognosis.
The pressure to perform “holiday cheer” is a burden shared by many in the cancer community. When friends and family gather, the expectation to mask one’s pain behind a “happy face” requires an expenditure of energy that many patients simply do not have. This forced performance of normalcy can deepen feelings of isolation, creating a chasm between the patient’s internal experience and the external requirements of festive tradition.
Chronology of the Holiday Struggle: A Seasonal Perspective
To understand the emotional trajectory of the season, one must look at the calendar through the lens of a patient:
- Pre-Holiday Preparations (Weeks Prior): The onset of the season brings the realization of physical limitations. Tasks once managed with ease—such as meal planning or cleaning—become markers of the impact of cancer. The necessity of delegating these tasks acts as a constant, silent reminder of the disease’s intrusion into daily life.
- The Eve of Rosh Hashanah: This period is often marked by a heightenened sense of reflection. As the community prepares for the “Day of Judgment,” patients often find themselves grappling with the theological weight of the liturgy.
- The Liturgical Experience: Specifically, the prayer Unetanneh Tokef, which asks, “Who shall live and who shall die?” serves as a potent trigger for those living with a diagnosis. The proximity of such existential questions to the personal reality of health crises can turn communal prayer into a moment of acute distress.
- The Holiday Meal: The act of dipping the apple in honey, meant to signify hope, can feel performative or even ironic to those currently in the thick of treatment.
Supporting Data: The Impact of Psychological Distress
The psychological impact of cancer during major life events is well-documented in oncology social work. According to data from various psycho-oncology studies, patients frequently report “Holiday Stress Syndrome,” characterized by:
- Increased Anxiety: Anticipatory anxiety regarding social interactions and the need to explain one’s health status to extended family members.
- Depressive Symptoms: The contrast between the celebratory atmosphere and the patient’s physical decline often triggers or exacerbates depressive episodes.
- Survivor’s Guilt: During communal gatherings, survivors often grapple with the complexity of their existence relative to others, particularly during high-stakes religious periods.
The Sharsheret approach—and the professional consensus in the field—suggests that acknowledging these feelings rather than suppressing them is the first step toward emotional stabilization.
Official Perspective: Reframing the Narrative
Shera Dubitsky, in her role at Sharsheret, emphasizes that the goal is not to abandon tradition, but to evolve it. By shifting the perspective from the “sugar coating” of the holiday to a deeper, more resilient understanding of the self, patients can reclaim their agency.
Redefining “Sweetness”
Rather than viewing the holiday through the lens of what is lost, Dubitsky suggests reframing the season as a reminder of the core elements of life that cancer cannot strip away. As one Sharsheret caller poignantly shared: "Even though I can’t keep cancer from invading my body, one thing I have come to realize is this: Cancer can’t touch my soul."
The Role of Emotional Fluidity
A critical component of this reframe is the validation of all emotions. The pressure to remain positive is a well-known phenomenon in cancer care, often referred to as "toxic positivity." However, research indicates that the suppression of negative emotions can lead to higher cortisol levels and increased physical distress. Allowing for the co-existence of tears and laughter is essential. Both serve as a means of catharsis—a way to cleanse the spirit and renew determination in the face of insurmountable odds.
Implications for Patients and Caregivers
The implications of this shift in perspective are significant for the broader cancer community. By normalizing the difficulty of the holidays, organizations and support systems can better equip patients to manage their expectations.
Practical Strategies for the Season
- Setting Boundaries: Patients are encouraged to limit their social obligations. If a large meal is too taxing, a smaller, more intimate gathering may be more appropriate.
- Delegation as Empowerment: Re-framing the need for help not as a sign of weakness, but as a strategic decision to conserve energy for what matters most.
- Spiritual Autonomy: For those triggered by specific prayers, it is perfectly acceptable to step out of the sanctuary or choose to focus on different aspects of the liturgy that provide comfort rather than confrontation.
- Community Connection: Engaging with support groups—such as those provided by Sharsheret—can provide a space where the “mask” of the holiday can be safely removed.
A Path Forward
The tenacity of the Jewish spirit, often symbolized by the apple, is not demonstrated solely through triumph, but through the ability to endure. By acknowledging the pain that the holidays can bring, and by giving oneself permission to experience that pain without judgment, individuals can find a different kind of sweetness—one that is rooted in authenticity and inner strength.
As we look toward the New Year, the message is clear: The honey does not have to coat everything. It is enough to find the small, protected spaces where peace still resides. Whether one is in the midst of treatment, in recovery, or navigating the complexities of long-term survivorship, the capacity to renew one’s spirit remains.
The holidays serve as an annual reminder that while life is fragile, it is also persistent. By embracing both the tears and the laughter, the community can foster a more compassionate, inclusive, and resilient approach to the New Year. Wishing all a year of genuine, deep-seated health and a spirit that remains, against all odds, entirely, vibrantly their own.
About the Author
